Hi and welcome. I'm going to say things that might sound horrendously mean. Please don't take them personally. I'm not holding a referendum on you, just your profile and some of the ways it is currently getting in the way of you finding what you want.
Got that? That it isn't mean for the sake of meanness? Good.
So, your profile is a train wreck. You've included your private conversations in several places, given far too clear a window into your relationship and scattered a multitude of red flags throughout.
Rather than go into detail, because it's every aspect, I'm just going to stick with a few before moving on to general guidelines.
So, strangers don't need to know who is in charge or how he feels when she's not happy. And it might be true that she's more fun when drinking, but in swinging it's a big ole red flag.
Your age range of 21 (15 years younger than her) to 45 (four years older than him) is also probably a more negative view into your processes than you realize. And if she doesn't think he's handsome, how do you think others are going to feel about the prospect of meeting him?
Looking For is for complete sentences about who you are looking for in a way that focuses on those people and not on you. And then what you are looking for, avoiding mention of what you aren't looking for.
Description is about you, mostly as a couple and only a little about you as individuals. It's best to avoid the awkward about him/about her thing.
Fantasies is generally meant for those fantasies you're actually thinking of including others in. It's not for bringing the things you turn each other on with into public view, not because that's wrong but because it's pointless.
Additional comments is probably where you say under what circumstances you might consider going beyond watching.
And that's all the time I have right now.
Good luck.