I generally don't do well reviewing couples since I'm not looking for them but since you only have your profile open to couples I'll take a stab at it. Standard disclaimer - this is all about the profile, not about you. I might like you but I really hate your profile.
Your profile is extremely off-putting. It is way too wordy - and way too negative. Most people do not spend a lot of time reading a profile (if they read it at all) so you have limited time to make a good impression and attract other people. You should be able to summarize the fun and interesting things about both of you (individually and as a couple) in less than a dozen sentences. You should be able to say what you are looking for and your fantasies in three or four sentences for each section. The legal bullshit has me rolling my eyes - how gullible do you want to appear? And your tagline is prime real estate - you are wasting it with poorly updated update info. If you want to note when you last updated text or photos put it in Additional Comments.
I gave up on your pictures after eight or ten. Please find a better way of obscuring your faces - the black sharpie isn't a good look. Velma's core photo advice is good - apply it and move all but the best dozen to another gallery if you want to keep them. Other than beach or pool photos move any scantily clad photos to a private gallery. Since you are obscuring your faces make sure you have several of the same photos in a private gallery with your faces showing - open it when initiating contact or replying to people you are interested in.
I have no specific ideas about how to appeal to other couples but I hope my observations at least give you some things to think about.
Good luck!
~Phoebert's Wife

