Everything you hear will be coming from a place of support from people that want you to succeed, but it may not sound like it. Honest feedback can sting a little (in this case probably a lot, so sorry in advance), so think of it like medicine: It may not leave a good taste in your mouth but it's meant to make things better.
The first thing that leaps out is your ages. We have some friends in the LS that are roughly your ages that went through something similar, and found they have to go to clubs to meet people. They just can't get a response online.
Why? Here's a synopsis of what they said: You'll find many folks that won't respond simply because you're (in their opinion) far too young to be in a truly committed relationship, you lack emotional maturity, they won't have anything in common with you, and/or they feel threatened by your youth.
You're fighting an uphill battle, so here's a few things I would recommend changing, keeping in mind you want to INCLUDE as many potential playmates as possible which means avoiding EXCLUDING as many people as possible:
You have lots of typos, misplaced punctuation and misspellings, all of which feed the narrative you're just a couple kids. Grammar across the board needs work. Write this in Word or something similar, look for the highlighted errors, correct them, then past it into your profile
The tagline reinforces the perception of your ages and maturity level. Find something that encourages people to reach out to you. Browse profiles from another city and steal something that makes YOU want to contact THEM.
"WE" is capitalized. It sends an aggressive message...WE are, implying some unnamed THEM is not. Let's hear the positives about you, and avoid anything that hints there's a THEM period.
Not everyone is looking for a unicorn. Lines like that alienate folks, which is the opposite of what you want to do. True story...whenever we read that in a profile, we automatically nope-the-fuck-out because it sends the message that they're really after Mrs C, and Mr C is being taken for the team.
Troll is not a word to use to describe someone in a profile.
There's a lot of words that give the feel you're plucking words out of a thesaurus to flesh out your profile. Write it in your own words, because that's who's going to be at the meet and greet.
The rest is...muddled. It's not clear, it's not consistent, and it's far too wordy. Thin it WAY down.
Velma will chime in on pics for sure, so listen to her. She knows what she's talking about. Here's my advice:
You're both great-looking people. You're pretty, he's handsome, you both have great bodies, but the pics don't do you justice.
In general, his pics (honestly) suggest he has the male equivalent of 'resting bitch face'. If he's not smiling in the pic, ditch it. He's handsome, but his blank look is very off-putting because it suggests he's emotionless/boring/dull. The fact your profile pic ONLY shows his mouth just enhances the perception. Re-crop so you can see both of your faces and SMILE.
This is going to sound harsher than anything said so far, but remember, it's meant to help: From junk in the "junk in the trunk" pics through bland expressions to a raised middle finger, there's something in each pic that might turn someone off. I'd literally start from scratch, take a bunch of new pics like Velma will recommend and SMILE.
Sorry if it stings. Remember it's meant to help.