Okay, I feel a little better after a night's sleep and my morning run, so let's get to it.
I'll start with the pictures.
I'm not a big fan of being assaulted by boobs and buts as soon as I land on a page. So there must be a classiness component to you because you say "We love wine and visiting festivals, trying new restaurants." But the boobs and butts don't help.
The part about being AA can help or hurt, depending on demographic. After all, nobody has ever said to my husband: "fuck me with that medium-sized Jewish cock." But I think you could lose eyeballs if you aren't perfect.
I was the only white, Jewish teacher in a 95% AA school for 15 years, so I've learned a thing our two, especially from my female AA teacher friends. AA is fine. Classy AA is fine. Thug AA is fine if that's what you are looking for, but when I look at you, you really don't fall into a type that is accessible to most people. You're kind of like ... a maybe classy AA couple? Maybe Thug? Maybe bougie? I have no idea. You're all over the map with your pictures and your spelling.
So I always say they you can't go wrong with classy. Throw out every single picture. The one of the male half in the plaid shirt and jeans is especially bad because it's the kind of outfit the middle son would wear to Red Lobster on Sunday after church. He should know better by now... but he doesn't. You know?
Remember, SLS isn't real. It's a way of showing everybody how hot and fun and interesting you are when all you really want to do is lie on the couch and watch Netflix. So I would come up with a narrative and stick to it.
Our narrative is the dirty teacher and the polished executive. Maybe your narrative could be classy AA business professionals? Even if it's not true - who cares?
I would get dressed up and take pictures like you are going to a corporate job. The male in a suit. The women in a dress and heels - maybe with a jacket. Take the pictures at a nicer hotel bar. Then, I want you to go to the shore and take a few pictures at the beach there with the two of you together. Finally, I want you to either go to a NY or Boston baseball game and take a few pictures together.
My intention is to establish a pattern. You are classy. You do interesting things. That should get you a lot more interest than what you have now. Then repost and we can refine.