For us, we scanned profiles and happened upon the profile of a couple that seemed very newbie friendly, and had posted a lot of advice in a more local forum.
We reached out to them, and they met us for dinner, and took us to their club as a guest. While we didn't play with them (we did with each other) that night, it gave us a sense of the atmosphere. They more than understood our pace, and did everything to make sure we were comfortable. We couldn't have picked a better couple. We still go to that club today. I'd recommend going to a club, even if you just have sex with each other. The sights and sounds are hot, and it's a great way to observe what's going on and how people behave. Most clubs are very welcome for new people.
We know of some meet and greets in New Jersey, and that's another place we see a lot of newbies and it's a no pressure way to meet others while having a couple of drinks in a relaxed atmosphere with no pressure.

